Monday, August 17, 2009

God's Problem (book review)

Bart D. Ehrman was an evangelical pastor who became an agnostic. He teaches Early Christian History at University of North Carolina. In God’s Problem: How the Bible Fails to Answer Our Most Important Question -Why We Suffer,  Ehrman reviews the biblical answers to the problem of evil in our world (Theodicy)…the answers that eventually left him unsatisfied that God exists…or that if he does, he’s not the god of the Bible.

It’s a difficult read, but not because of his writing style. Ehrman writes this to be read by people who aren’t as steeped in history or theology. He even includes quite a bit of his own journey, while keeping to the task at hand. What was difficult (but, I believe, necessary) was to read 250 pages about human suffering and, as a person of Christian faith, to meditate on it without the “clear” answers that so many people (innocently enough) give to this complicated problem.

His main contention is that the Bible provides several different and even contradictory answers to the problem of evil. He highlights five of these answers culled from biblical prophecy, history, wisdom literature, the gospels and the apocalyptic books (Daniel and Revelation). Ironically, Ehrman ends up with a thoroughly biblical answer to the problem of evil. This he finds in the book of Ecclesiastes…life is short and unpredictable so be sure to enjoy the good while it lasts.

One thing that I thoroughly appreciated about Ehrman’s approach is that he refuses to leave suffering as a philosophical problem…something abstract or out there. It’s heartbreaking to keep bringing up terrible atrocities, natural disasters, child starvation…but it’s not as bad as abstracting these things. There is simply no moral way to deal with the problem while ignoring the particularities.

I also was impressed by how Ehrman shares the relevant texts and his interpretation in a non-pushy, exploring way while still demonstrating that the Hebrew and Christian scriptures just don’t manifest the perfectly cohesive worldview that ‘true believers’ often proclaim. It reminds me of how some people proclaim that Islam is a religion of peace while others quote the Koran’s ugliest sections. These biblical texts are difficult to read. Some are even embarrassing! And perhaps they should be.

His presentation of Apocalyptic was so clear and refreshing. I am only dissatisfied that he seems to have Jesus (according to the Gospels) and Paul as apocalypticists in the ancient Hebrew mold without mentioning the differences (what makes Christian apocalyptic unique from Hebrew, other than simply ‘Jesus’). For example, he stresses apocalyptic’s stresses on dualism, immanence, vindication and pessimism. In this regard, he seems to be rebelling against his fundamentalist backgrounds or popular Western constructs of Revelation rather than wrestling with other recent scholars (N.T. Wright or the Radical Orthodoxy crowd). I feel that, with the exception of ‘vindication’, his problems with dualism, immanence and pessimism could use further discussion with other scholars.

It’s very difficult for me, for example, to believe that Jesus in the Gospels is saying that because only God can make the world right, it’s really meaningless what we do. I’ve heard an evangelical pastor teach this very thing about the mess that the environment is in. Standing up to this otherwise good man was infuriating. But, while modern heresies might teach this sort of thing, I don’t see it in either the gospels or Paul’s writings.

Is it possible that the problem of suffering is NOT our most important question? If I had an audience with Ehrman, I would be interested to hearing his plausible answers to’ the problem of good’. Yes, human beings are capable of experiencing suffering in a way that seems unique from all other creatures. But, as he emphasizes in his conlusion, we’re also capable of experiencing the good in a way that is just as unique. Our experience of the good, of transcendence, of pleasure might even be more unique to humans than the experience of suffering. Why is this? What answers can we proffer for the existence of good in our world?

As long as the problem of suffering or the consistency of biblical witness (according to modern tastes) remain in the fore, I really sympathize with Ehrman. He’s written a passionate and compassionate book about a problem that isn’t going away soon. It may be hard for a fundamentalist to become a historical critic without losing their faith…like a camel passing through the eye of the needle.

As for me, the philosophical problem of evil, however difficult, still isn’t determinative. Neither is the idea of consistency within the biblical texts (whose diversity understandably flummoxes hard-boiled modernists).

The determining ‘problems’ for this person remain Jesus and his Church. I still believe there are better solutions to the bad faith Ehrman inherited (or chose, depending on your presuppositions) as a young man than no faith.I think we can ‘unleash the scriptures’ (to borrow from Stanley Hauerwas) without leaving the faith altogether.

[Via http://charismanglican.com]

Sunday, August 16, 2009

When the Circle of Life is a Noose

Stefanie Wilder-Taylor, the blogger who runs babyonbored, is a mother who is no longer drinking. She’s also written at least three books, celebrating the grind of baby-raising,  the most recent one:  It’s not Me, It’s You, falls, according to the New York Times, into the “antiperfection mom-lit” world. A bold new category.

I am relieved that there is such a category. I am sad that it did not exist 20, 40 or 60 years ago, when it was just as necessary as today.

Stefanie Wilder-Taylor's book for today's moms

Wilder-Taylor writes with the acerbic, honest style we have come to admire and expect of the women we blazed the trail for. We were the generation who felt the same despair, the same fear, the same inadequacy. We sat on our stoops drinking chardonnay out of sippy cups,  frightened and alone, wondering what had happened to our identities. We were “Jimmy’s mom” or “Darla’s mom” and we wore shirtwaists when we felt we wanted to belong and blue jeans when we did not.

We looked at photos of moms with a baby held softly to her breast, her face a picture of composure. The baby was blond and mom had long, perfect hair falling over the nursing breast, as they sat in the shade of a big oak, protected and safe. Both baby and mom were swathed in white eyelet. Motherhood was nothing like that for us. We had on damp, sour-smelling button-front blouses. Underneath were bulky nursing bras, also damp from spurting milk. Our nipples were raw and the baby was screaming. Our hair was unwashed and smeared with our tears and the baby’s snot. We knew we were inadequate mothers.

We were alone in the suburbs. Just out of college, where our career choices were limited to secretary, nurse, or teacher  we had not wanted any of those. Marriage was a chance to get out of our parents’ house before they could guilt us into staying to serve an endless row of TV dinners on plastic tray tables. We had wandered out in search of that wonderful man who would support us, babies who would delight us, and a life spent in the delights of being a “homemaker,” the highest goal a woman could aspire to.

We’ d been lied to. Homemaking was a boring stupor of cleaning, washing, folding, ironing and cooking, which repeated in endless cycles. We then braved the men’s world,  walking into the places we could find identities, we were scorned by both the men and our friends.

The surprise is that the men were not interested in seeing “the little woman” in a business role. We struggled with emotions that promised that the cute girl got the cute guy, using the same “teddy-bear tricks” we’d used in college. It didn’t move us up the ladder of success; more often we were bedded down instead of helped up. Mentoring was for men. The other women in the workplace looked like friends, but were competitors.

Unlike Taylor-Wilder, we did not have the support of strangers that Wilder-Taylor got from her blog–”People have been loving me right through the Internet,” she says of the help.  Instead, we were the generation exemplified by June Carter (as played by Reese Witherspoon in Walk the Line), confronted by an angry store clerk for leaving her first husband. “I can’t imagine your parents still talking to you. You are an abomination,” hissed the angry woman. “I’m so sorry I disappointed you,” answers June, an answer that would be impossible today.

When I tell younger women that I was sent home from work for wearing a 3-piece, long-sleeved pants suit, they laugh. When I tell younger women that I was fired from my job when I got married, and from another when I got pregnant, they think I’m joking. But it happened, and not so long ago.

Most of us felt alone. When Marilyn French’s The Women’s Room hit the market around 1978, most of us

Marilyn French's book came out in 1978

read it with recognition, relief, and hope. Thirty years passed between the two books. Both point to a society that hasn’t done much to solve the serious problems women face as both the breadwinner and the caretaker. We’ve come around full circle. There are women CEOs, women in politics and medicine. And women in despair, holding their babies. Feminism was forgotten, written off as a phase of bra-burning. It’s time to bring it back. As a real-life approach to helping women and men create a stronger bond at work and at home.

Note: Marilyn French died in May of 2009.

–Quinn McDonald is a writer, life- and creativity coach. You can see her business site at QuinnCreative.com and visit her art journaling site at Raw-Art-Journals.com (c) QuinnCreative 2009 All rights reserved.

[Via http://quinncreative.wordpress.com]

Contrasting views on cheapness

We’ve maintained from the start that there is more to frugality than merely being cheap. Frugality is about deploying your resources wisely, to maximise your long-term happiness.

One thing that makes me happy is being satisfied about the ethical or moral consequences of my spending, so it’s worrying to read accounts of what happens behind the scenes to bring us truly cheap goods:

… in her lively and terrifying book “Cheap: The High Cost of Discount Culture,” Ellen Ruppel Shell pulls back the shimmery, seductive curtain of low-priced goods to reveal their insidious hidden costs. Those all-you-can-eat Red Lobster shrimps may very well have come from massive shrimp-farming spreads in Thailand, where they’ve been plumped up with antibiotics and possibly tended by maltreated migrant workers from Burma, Cambodia and Vietnam. The made-in-China toy train you bought your kid a few Christmases ago may have been sprayed with lead paint — and the spraying itself may have been done by a child laborer, without the benefit of a protective mask.

from a review at Salon.

The book is also reviewed at Boingboing, with some really interesting debate in the comments.

Then there’s this view of so-called ethical consumption, in a review in spiked online of Neal Lawson’s All Consuming:

Ironically, even the most fashion-conscious teenager is less obsessed with consumption than today’s anti-consumerists. The learned professors, journalists and political lobbyists who study in detail the choices available to the public are a sorry sight.

Of course such self-appointed experts are not opposed to all forms of consumption. Although they despise the purchase of luxury items by the masses they are happy to indulge what they see as their own refined tastes. Indeed, the notion of ethical consumption is essentially a way of validating the shopping of the elite while deriding the masses at the same time.

From the elite’s perspective, consumption becomes what author James Heartfield calls ‘status affirmation’. The purchase of what are deemed to be ethically acceptable products is seen as marking individuals out from the rabble. So anyone who likes, say, ordinary chocolate biscuits is sneered at as a gullible consumer while those who eat overpriced organic Duchy Originals are viewed as cultured individuals.

from here. And there is something in that. It isn’t much of an advance to replace one sort of snobbery with another. But still, if one kind of snobbery is helpful to others while another isn’t, I’ll opt for the first over the second.

But what if we don’t buy new things at all? What if we only buy old things and reuse them, or recycle goods?

… salvage itself is a mechanism, both in practice and in thought, procedure and ideology, deeply ingrained in the circuits of late capitalism. And much further back than that.

From the total inanity of green “upcycled” goods (“ie. recycled/reclaimed into something special”, because “Ethical is Beautiful” and they insist on “only using laptops“) to wrenching fillings from your teeth to sell to Cash For Gold U.S.A. (for the oral hoarding days must come to an end in these lean times). From the total staggering obscenity of price mark-ups at trendy vintage clothing shops to desperate children rummaging through the stinking mountains of trash. These are apocalyptic times generally, but in particular, the figure and action of salvage looms perhaps largest.

from Putting the Punk back in Salvage, pointed out by Giovanni Tiso. Particular venom is reserved for vintage clothing, which hurts me.

Dear reader, you must decide what to do for yourself. If you have a coherent plan, please share.

[Via http://frugalme.wordpress.com]

The Diddakoi - Rumer Godden

I remember Rumer Godden from my childhood. The one I remember the most is An Episode of Sparrows but I always knew she was a wonderful writer. She wrote a number of fabulous books some of which were co-authored with her sister, Jon Godden. She was born Margaret Rumer Godden and wrote under her pen name of Rumer Godden.

I’ve managed to pick up a few of her books including their autobiographical novel Two Under the Indian Sun. I’ve seen a few copies of The Diddakoi which was televised as Kizzy about a young girl who is half gypsy finding herself an orphan at the age of 7. Only one copy is available on the website as the other two have been totally wrecked by much reading and some enterprising person had stapled the pages together making it very challenging to read the inner edge of many of the pages. I’m not keen on throwing books out but at times it’s necessary such as when they’re mouldy or totally soaked or stapled together along the edge or even when someone has cut out the innards. I’ve seen all four problems and put these books carefully into the recycling.

I read The Diddakoi with much interest as I’m totally fascinated by gypsies and know so little about them. I found myself being very sympathetic towards them. They have customs which are rather alien to the regular housedweller and in the past this meant something to make fun of and be mean about. At the age of 7 Kizzy was sent to school. She had never been there before and didn’t know how to fit in, nor did she want to. One day she was taken to her grandmother’s wagon to be told of her Gran’s death. Poor Kizzy, her whole life turned upside down, Gran’s wagon burnt and her things broken or distributed and she herself was not wanted. She did what so many people have done in the past, she ran away only she ended up in Admiral Twiss’ house being nursed with pneumonia. Anyway, after many trials and tribulations she finds herself with family and friends. During the course of the book we learn many things about gypsies and I found myself re-evaluating some of the things I do.

It’s meant to be a book for children but I would recommend it to people of any age as it’s always good to see how other people live.

[Via http://suzsspace.wordpress.com]

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Book Review: Bones of Faerie

Summary: Liza has been told of the war with the faeries that destroyed the human world. She’s been told, like everyone else in her town, to cast out anything that shows remnants of faerie magic. But Liza is haunted by the memory of her sister, cast out and left to be eaten by wild animals as a newborn because of the color of her hair. That was the night before her mother left. Now Liza is seeing things, and knows she, too, has been tainted. If she is to keep the rest of her town from harm, she must flee.

Review: Bones of Faerie is the best faerie story I’ve read in a long, long time. No shallow characters, no stupid love triangles, no lumps on a girl’s back turning into wings, no girl who is really gorgeous that thinks she’s ugly… No, this book is real. This book is cold and sharp. We aren’t told much about the War, which some reviewers have said annoyed them. But while it did make me wonder what really happened, I felt like it left something open for me to wonder about. And I like a book where EVERYTHING isn’t known and tied in a perfect bow by the end. Liza was very realistic. You could see the attraction between Matthew and her, and Simner didn’t make that too cheesy. She just let it flow. Kudos! There were no really ‘big’ revelations, but there were some small ones that kind of surprised me a little. The book wasn’t a mystery novel though, so I wasn’t expecting a big turnaround. Simner’s writing was elegant, somewhat simplistic, but perfect for this story. I couldn’t stop reading it. I was planning on just reading a little every night, but that just.. didn’t work out. I had to read it during the day too and finished it in two days. I liked that there wasn’t much focus on the faeries, but that Simner focused on the character Liza and her problems. But the faeries were still worked in. All the imagery around the plants was incredible, too. And making the plants evil in their own way was just wonderfully imaginative. It’s a very quick read, and pretty short, too.

So in all, I strongly recommend this if you’re looking for a good faerie story, and not another cheesy love triangle. Also, if you want a nice, quick, satisfying read.

Available at your local Wake County Public Library!

[Via http://wakecounty.wordpress.com]

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

A Devil to Play – Obsessing on the French Horn

A Devil to Play – Obsessing on the French Horn

Rating: The Half Way There Read

This is a follow-up post to my last entry, the one about the horn. I’m back at my desk and picked up the book for a lunch time read. The book’s title is “A Devil to Play, One Man’s Year-Long Quest to Master the Orchestra’s Most Difficult Instrument”. The author is  Jasper Rees and the publisher is Harper. A quick overview of the book, this is lifted not word-for-word from the inside flap, is that the author tried to play the French horn as a teen but abandoned it after two lessons. As an adult, he’s overcome with an obsession to learn to play the horn and perform with a home-grown concert group one year later.

I understand the obsessive nature of the author, I’ve decided that I would learn to speak German and Spanish, learn higher math to astonish my friends and influence people, and learn a wide-variety of crafts to make tons of money. None of these things has happened, but since the author wrote the book I’m guessing he actually accomplished his goal.

While reading the book I realized I don’t know what a French horn sounds like. I hopped over to YouTube and searched for French horn performances. There are several but I chose this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUES5PA0ALg. I like the way the solo fits into the performance.

The horn sounded different than I expected, rougher and less polished than most brass instruments. I often try to match up sounds or flavors with each other, like what would a French horn taste like? I’m not thinking of licking the brass, more like trying to assign a flavor profile to the sound it makes. I thought vanilla bean, or caramel, but these flavors  didn’t really catch the tone the way I heard it. I ended up with Guinness Extra Stout with its hint of toasted malt and burnt chocolate aroma. The sound is very rich, smooth but not without a good, nubby texture.

I may not give the book a Best Friend Read, even though it does have a lot of history woven through the narrative. It’s a good read but I don’t think I have enough interest in musical instruments to carry me through to the end. I will browse it, and I’ll probably go to BevMo and pick up a couple of bottles of Guinness.

[Via http://bookweasel.wordpress.com]

Book Review #1 - Here I Am To Worship

I recently finished the book Here I Am To Worship by Tim Hughes. Tim Hughes is a Worship Leader from England who has written some amazing worship songs. His book is thick with wisdom for the Worship Leader and Worship band members alike.

In the book Hughes starts off explaining worship,  what it is, “Worship is our all consuming response to God” and where our worship should come from., “When our eyes truly see Jesus, and our hearts comprehend His life-changing love…His love will burst forth from us”. The next 7 chapters layout his methods on Worship Leading, Leading a Band, Choosing Songs, Musical Dynamics, and others.

It’s obvious to see that Hughes’ number 1 priority is Glorifying God, and  he happens to do that through Worship Leading. I would recommend this book to both worship leaders and worship band members.

[Via http://soulspire.wordpress.com]