I have been a real fan of A.C. Grayling’s books of essays for some time. His wit and the directness of his thinking are unusual in this era of spin and style. So I was intrigued when I found out he had written this book – subtitled “The story of the struggles for liberty and rights that made the modern west”. It is certainly a subject that demands attention in this age of patriot acts, terrorism and counter-terrorism. The theme that the rights and liberties that we enjoy thoughtlessly in the west were hard won by our forebears is one that is an important reminder for us here and now, in New Zealand as in any other western democracy. After reading this book, though, I somehow left it much as I had entered it, feeling that it was a weighty subject that deserved a thorough treatment. It’s not that this is a bad book – it is in fact quite good – just that it feels like it should be a great book given the subject matter in order to do it justice. And, indeed, after reading this book I felt that I had only scratched the surface of the topic. So, a worthy introduction, but I am waiting for the in depth study.
Monday, September 7, 2009
Book Review: The Joy of Ministry
Thomas W. Currie III. The Joy of Ministry. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2008. xiii+126 pgs.
In this work Thomas Currie skillfully weaves theology, spiritual formation, and pastoral insight in a work with a title that many would consider an oxymoron. The proposal of this book is that “nothing is more crucial to the future of the church’s own life and ministry that the recovery of the gospel’s gift of joy (3).” The possession of the disciple according to Jesus, Currie sets out to show ministers how joy can be their possession, or perhaps more accurately, possess them.
The fundamental thrust throughout most of the work is the rejection of gnosticism in the work of ministry. Much joy-sucking frustration pastors experience can be blamed, according to Currie, by not taking the physical nature of the church seriously enough. The church is made up of real people, who often fall dreadfully short of the gospel’s ideal.
Rather than seeking to find the perfect church, the minister instead should realize that an ecclesiology than is grounded in Christology is not mired in shame over it’s shortcomings, but rather finds even in its filth an occasion for joy in their salvation, made possible by the Son who “for the joy set before him endured the cross . . .” Thus Currie argues that both the sin and hardships that accompany embodied life, real ministry, can be occasions for gratefulness and to help people focus on Jesus Christ and not themselves.
Currie draws heavily on the work of Karl Barth & Fyoder Dostoyevsky’s novel The Brothers Karamazov to urge pastors to lead their congregations away from their preoccupation with busyness & the loathing of their failures to take time to bask in the glow of God’s “irresponsible grace.” This book, regardless of one’s theological sensibilities, is a treasure to both scholars and pastors in its call to stop taking ourselves so seriously, in both our achievements and failures, and to instead find joy in our salvation. This is message sorely needed today.
Saturday, September 5, 2009
Summer 2009 Wrap Up
This is a list of books I read this summer but didn’t have the time or inclination to review in detail. So this will be brief:
Crispin: The Cross of Lead by Avi – A work of historical fiction that won the Newbery in 2003. Crispin is a young boy whose mother has just died. He is soon on the run (accused of a crime he did not commit) being declared a wolf’s head (meaning anyone may kill him). The secret to his sudden fall from obscurity lies in the identity of his father. A great read but not a favorite, if you know what I mean. I hate the cover! I think it has been a turn off for a lot of young patrons, who might otherwise gravitate toward it as the language is very accessible.
Someone Like You by Sarah Dessen – Not my favorite Dessen but an okay read. Clearly one of her earlier books. I was dying to know if Michael’s parents replied to Scarlett’s letter. Dessen certainly has a hang up when it comes to Mother/Daughter relationships. Regarding teen boys, they have ranged from the wonderful (Along for the Ride and Just Listen) to average (Someone Like You) to terrible (Dreamland).
The End of Overeating: Taking Control of the Insatiable American Appetite by David Kessler – You wouldn’t believe how you are being manipulated by the restaurant industry. Fat, sugar and salt (the three points of the compass) combine to trick your mind into eating more and more and more food you do not need. What’s worse, they stick healthy sounding names (like Spinach Dip) on the dishes to mislead you. Read this book. Take back control!
Review: The Boy with the Topknot
The Boy with the Topknot
by Sathnam Sanghera
There is nothing about this book that yells at me to pick it up and read it. Not the cover, not the blurb. Nothing. Subtitled as “A Memoir of Love, Secrets and Lies in Wolverhampton” the back cover sells it as a trip down memory lane and hints at a few family skeletons. Big deal. Added to that, it was really difficult to find, so if wasn’t for the local Reading Group suggesting it as a title, I would have never even heard of it A shame really, because what the blurb fails to mention the one thing that held me throughout: mental illness.
Sathnam was in his mid twenties before he realised his father was taking medication for schizophrenia. This revelation takes him on a journey of research and discovery, learning that his sister also has the condition, developed while she revised for her school exams. But his main focus is his mother, and how she coped with her arranged marriage, domestic violence and life in a land where she couldn’t speak the language.
As a memoir, it is certainly engaging, deeply moving and peppered with humour. On the down side, Sathnam’s own neurosis never lets up. His internal debates and worries are an important element of the book because one of the main threads is Sathnam’s desire to get his mother to understand his own struggle of feeling trapped between worlds, and that his British side is equally as important to him as his Indian side, but it ends up becoming irritating and getting in the way of the characters you really want to know more about. I’m trying not to be too harsh on this point because the book is a personal memoir, and written subjectively, but at times he just irritates and overpowers everything in his path.
Overall, The Boy With the Topknot reads well and is a fascinating secret window on a world that would otherwise remain locked in its box, but on finishing, I couldn’t help feeling it would benefit from some heavy editing.
BOOKS: Two new books on Bonnie & Clyde
This week’s Texas Observer has my long review of two new books on Bonnie & Clyde: Bonnie and Clyde: The Lives Behind the Legend, by Paul Schneider (Henry Holt, 384 pages, $24), the other is Go Down Together:
The True, Untold Story of Bonnie and Clyde, by Jeff Guinn (Simon & Schuster, 468 pages, $27). If you only have money for one, I suggest the Jeff Guin book, which is a solid account with lots of great, reliable new scholarship on Texas’ most infamous outlaw couple. Schneider has the more sympathetic take on the duo and he stresses that Bonnie was actually a beauty; the photos don’t usually flatter her and she didn’t smoke cigars, she just posed with one for the heck of it. She was also a budding actress, in addition to being a poet. But that’s all you’ll get here, please see the Observer for the full review. See the clip below of Bonnie & Clyde’s death car.
Friday, September 4, 2009
Jesus: The Final Days
Craig Evans & NT Wright. Jesus: The Final Days. Louisville, KY. Westminster John Knox, 2009
Many thanks to WJK for the review copy.
Simply stated, the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus are the center of the Christian faith. We are many things as Christians, but I would think it fair to say that we are all that we are chiefly because we follow the Jesus the Messiah, whom we worship as the crucified and risen Lord. As such, the subject of what we can know about these crucial events is very important indeed. Toward that end, Troy Miller (Crichton College) has done us the service of putting into book format the 2003 and 2004 Crichton College Church and Academy lectures, given by NT Wright and Craig Evans, respectably, which detail the historical background of these events.
The book is short and to the point (roughly 100 pages). Being based on lectures, there are no footnotes or endnotes and the only bibliography to speak of consists of two or three references for further reading at the end of each chapter. It is divided into three parts, corresponding to the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus.
In Part 1, Craig Evans sets out to paint us a picture of the crucifixion and death of the Messiah. After a quick run through of the historical written affirmations of Jesus’ death (biblical and otherwise), he delves into the reasons why Jesus was crucified in the first place. Evans focuses here on the actual situation “on the ground” in 1st century Palestine, not on the theological import of the event. The triumphal entry, the cleansing of the temple, and the parables of judgment on the temple establishment are all unpacked and defended historically as plausible and legitimate offenses that could and would have lead to Jesus’ being perceived as a political threat. Evans then argues, based not least on Gethsemane narratives and the death of John the Baptist, that Jesus plausibly could have, in fact, anticipated his own death, and spoken of this to his followers.
From there, Evans discusses in detail Jesus’ trial and mockery. The detail of this section is pretty remarkable, considering the length (15 pages or so). Obviously the gospels get the longest treatment here as sources, but Evans also touches on allusions to the trial in Peter’s sermons in the Book of Acts, as well as Paul’s letters. His contention that Jesus’ drawing together of Daniel 7 and Psalm 110 in his confession before the high priest would have been seen as blasphemous won’t be new to those who have read much in this area, but given the implied audience of a book of this length, it may very well be the first time that some have heard this line of reasoning. Evans then goes on to discuss the Passover pardon of Barabbas, and it is here (the first of many places) that his mastery of the primary sources really shines. Using both Jewish and Roman sources, he shows that criminal pardons (of prisoners sentenced to crucifixion) were a political and historical reality in the 1st century. I found his quotation of the Mishna (m. Pesahim 8:6) particularly interesting:
“ …they may slaughter (the Passover lamb) for one…whom they have promised to bring out of prison (on the Passover)”
Some discussion of the political situation that Pilate found himself in, and some interesting tidbits regarding the mockery of Jesus round the conversation out, before moving on to the crucifixion itself, where again Evans is masterful in his knowledge of the relevant background material. Lastly, Evans focuses on the theological implications of Jesus’ crucifixion, and the foolishness (if I can use that word) that a crucified messiah would have been seen as in the first century. On the whole, one could think of this last section of Part 1 as a very selective condensation of Martin Hengel’s Crucifixion, boiled down to about three pages (!). Good stuff.
Part Two, also by Evans, looks in some detail at the burial of Jesus. The chapter begins with some background on the history of Jewish burial practices. Again, Evans’ knowledge of 2nd Temple history and material really shines here. This section was the most interesting for me, and it is short enough that you can read it through a few times to let it all soak in. Moving from Jewish to Roman burial practices at the time of Jesus, Evans devotes a couple of pages to the discovery of a Jewish crucifixion victim’s ossuary (with the nail apparently still in the heel), which is a very good read. Citing Pliny the Elder, Plautus, and various inscriptions, he then discusses Roman tendencies regarding burials for criminals, and responds to those who would argue that the apparently small number of buried crucifixion victims found suggests that Jesus would not have been given a proper burial at all. Lastly, he briefly recounts the gospel accounts of Jesus’ burial, and argues that based on the evidence discussed and the texts themselves, they deserve a fair reading.
The Bishop NT Wright takes up the topic of Jesus’ resurrection for the third and final chapter of the book. The chapter is very good, but this information is so readily available elsewhere, whether in book, essay, or various lectures, that it is hard to be too excited about if you’ve already read or heard Wright on the resurrection (and most probably have). I won’t attempt to sum up his work on the matter in a few words, but it’s widely available in various formats. If somehow you’ve not been exposed to the Bishop’s work on the subject, this is probably a good, if very truncated introduction to it. Just to put this in perspective, Wright’s The Resurrection of the Son of God gave him roughly 700 pages to devote to the topic. A shorter, wonderful treatment of Jesus’ resurrection, along with related topics, can be found in Surprised By Hope, which runs about 300 pages. Here, he gets about 35 pages. As a result, this chapter is basically unnecessary for the reader who has read either of the books above, or heard any of Wright’s many lectures on the subject (available here). The chapter is good for what it is, but why buy the postcard when you could have the full-color painting?
To sum up:
It is hard to imagine a better book if you are looking for a short and informative discussion of the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus. Craig Evan’s two chapters are particularly good, and pack a great deal of information into a small number of pages. Even those who have read other works in this vein will probably learn something here, or at least be given something new to ponder. The final chapter, by Bishop Wright, is good, but is eclipsed by both Surprised By Hope and The Resurrection of the Son of God, both of which are worth buying in their own right, and highly recommended. This doesn’t detract from the value of the book, however, and for the price it is hard to beat.
Thursday, September 3, 2009
Three Cups of Tea by Greg Mortenson
You may have seen your parents reading this book. It is the exciting and inspiring true story of a man who has dedicated his life to promoting peace through education. Now there are two children’s versions of the worldwide bestseller: the CPS library has the picture book (Listen to the Wind) and this Young Reader’s Edition. Read it and find out what the rest of the world is talking about!
When mountaineer Greg Mortenson got lost in the Pakistani mountains after a failed attempt at climbing K2, he was rescued by the villagers in the poor village of Korphe. As he was nursed back to health, Mortenson was shocked to learn that Korphe’s children had no school, with lessons taught outdoors just three days a week. Kids learned to write using sticks in the dirt. To repay the village’s kindness, Mortenson promised to return, and help build a school. He did return, and he eventually built more than FIFTY schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan! Reading a book like this is inspiring, educational, and can help a child feel connected to the larger world.